Lead Linked to Violence

The link between lead and crime has been published everywhere from science journals to  Forbes to Mother Jones. Violent crime in the United States rose in the 1960s, spiked in the 90s, and has plummeted since then. Why did the generation associated with peace signs and hippies turn out to be the most violent in recent history?  Many scientists point to one reason–lead in gasoline during their childhoods.

Lead in the form of tetraethyl lead was added to gasoline in the 1920s in to help electric igniting engines operate more smoothly. It worked well despite one problem with it. The additive was known to cause “madness” and hallucinations. This had been first documented in the 1850s. In fact, workers at the first lead additive manufacturing plant died after going “looney.” Despite this, the additive worked effectively and was cheap so the companies that made it pushed forward to add it to gasoline. It was temporarily banned in parts of the nation–not the Midwest however–making the breadbasket of our nation a rich source of environmental lead. With careful marketing and lobbying by the companies that made the additive, the health effects were downplayed and the new technology was given a clean bill of health by the U.S. Surgeon General in the late 1920s.Thus, leaded gasoline was heavily used across the United States for over forty years.

Analytical chemistry upped its game in the 1970s, finding that the lead persisted in the environment and in people. Many states began phasing it out in the 70s and 80s. It was banned state by state and eliminated from car gasoline in 1996.  But since it is an element, lead can’t break down into anything simpler. Scientists believe that everyone over 40 in the U.S. has some degree of lead poisoning. Lead can be cleared from blood by the body but it resides in bones for 30 years or longer. Lead still lingers in many locations in the U.S.–including the poorest most violent neighborhoods. And of course, it has recently been found in water in Flint, Michigan thanks to corroding old pipes. Old paint and even old cans can also add lead to our bodies. However, lead in gasoline has been by far the most egregious contributor. As use was curtailed, lead in blood began to drop dramatically. Crime did as well.

lead-in-blood
This diagram is from the journal Analytical Chemistry, Feb. 1986

Why is lead so nasty? Lead impairs brain growth and poisons neurons.. It lows IQ and leads to life-long mental impairment. It damages the areas of the brain that control aggression and is more toxic to boys than to girls. It contributes to ADHD. It encourages cancer. Even teen-pregnancy has been linked to lead exposure. The poorer a person is, the more likely they are to have a high blood lead level.

It’s no surprise that lead is found at high levels in shooting ranges. These are regulated by OSHA and there are rules demanding clean up but these rules are not always followed. Eating meat shot with lead is also dangerous, especially for children. Adding vinegar to game shot with lead bullets makes the lead even more soluble in the meat and increases the toxicity.

Shooting ranges are not the only source of lead in the environment. Fuel for small airplanes contains lead and they are one of the major contributors to lead pollution today.

The link between lead poisoning and crime needs to be explored more fully. The tragedy of lead poisoning in the Unites States is a sad tale of greed and lack of regulation. Every one of us has suffered to some extent from exposure to lead. The cautionary take-away is that when it comes to chemicals, we need more regulations and more care taken before approving them for use in consumer products.

6 thoughts on “Lead Linked to Violence

  1. Kyle W.

    Fascinating and frightening. I especially appreciate your reference to lead being an element. When I don’t deal with those “kernels” day to day, it’s easy to forget, but now I remember.:-)

    Your post made me think of the Franklin Expedition – the possibility that some crew died of lead poisoning. However, I see that more recent research tends to discount that possibility in favor of zinc deficiency http://www.nature.com/news/fingernail-absolves-lead-poisoning-in-death-of-arctic-explorer-1.21128 and exposure to the elements https://www.theguardian.com/science/2014/jan/26/lead-poisoning-polar-sir-john-franklin

    When my dad was stationed in Germany in the early 1980’s, a small number of German gas stations had unleaded fuel at the time; the catalytic converter on his American car had to be removed to avoid damage to it from the leaded gasoline.

    Thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Kyle W.

        Excellent question. Since John Hartnell’s body was the only one a fingernail was recovered from, researchers weren’t able to determine if the other men had the same condition or not. The tests they ran showed that the men’s lead exposure didn’t spike during the expedition, only the last few weeks of their lives: “Hartnell had relatively high levels of lead only during his last few weeks, when his dying body probably broke down and released long-stored lead from his bones into his blood and nails, Christensen says.” http://www.nature.com/news/fingernail-absolves-lead-poisoning-in-death-of-arctic-explorer-1.21128#/b1 . Your article and this thread inspired me to look up more about Franklin’s lost expedition; I will definitely be reading more on the event and findings. Thanks again!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Zinc is interesting. Once I had a student do zinc tests on hair. They found that zinc levels varied with the color of hair. In fact, she compared her dog’s grey hair with that of human grey hair and the levels were similar. Sadly, I can’t remember what color hair had the most zinc but the grey hair was lower in zinc as I remember.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Kyle W.

    From the various sources I have read, it appears that the book is still open, so to speak, on the effects of lead exposure to Franklin, Crozier, and their respective crews. It was fascinating to read in “Frozen in Time: The Fate of the Franklin Expedition” how the powers that be misjudged the canned meats and vegetables to have the needed ascorbic qualities to help prevent scurvy. This article provides a summary of the lead poisoning and other theories: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1279489/ .

    Like

    1. Yes, it’s true that Vitamin C has a short shelf life–a reason to rely on fresh fruits for it and not canned food or old vitamins. I think somewhere on this blog I have a post about the vitamins in frozen foods and really, they are best if consumed within six months.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s